YBNBY Logo
{ July 26, 2006 Archives }
ornate line
A Giant Leap for Scientific Credibility

200607261714

What is The Truth? I've had a hard time with this one lately-it's tough to come by, and you'll almost never find it in the news-except maybe for reporting of accidents or yesterday's weather. I'd like to think that scientists come close to The Truth by asking highly specific questions, creating well designed experiments to answer them, and then presenting their results as "Proof".

The peer review process for scientific publication has long been criticized as a subjective and inadequate measure of scientific work. There has been a recent rise in retracted scientific works due to inaccuracies, data fabrication, and failures to reproduce published data independantly. (to see who's been naughty-check the case summaries here)

In addition, there are many scientists who believe their works are unfairly rejected due to conflicts of interest among reviewers, bias against less established scientists, bias against "less sexy stories", or results that conflict with what is considered "conventional wisdom".

Historically:
A paper is submitted to a journal by the scientists who performed the experiments and analyzed the data.
The journal editors do a primary internal review to determine if the submitted work is appropriate for the journal.
The editors then select outside reviewers to read the manuscript and comment on the scientific merit of the work and the validity of the conclusions drawn based on the data presented and recommend to Accept, Revise, or Reject. These reviewers remain anonymous.
These comments are forwarded to the authors who respond with a rebuttal or additional data.
The process may repeat itself with a revised manuscript, or the journal editors may make a final decision to accept or reject.

The journal Nature is opening the process to the scientific public with online publication of manuscripts under review, for open comment and scientific discussion. A bold step forward indeed.

Leave a comment on "A Giant Leap for Scientific Credibility"...
ornate line
How many candy bars are they selling, anyway?

InstantDef.jpg

Snickers is all over the place these days. We've already talked about the outdoor campaign. Then today I read about a new site featuring a series of webisodes with the Black Eyed Peas. I cannot begin to imagine how much they dropped on this thing. From where I'm sitting, they're some of the dumbest clips I've seen on the web. Then again, Snickers is going after teens and twenty-somethings, and I'm eleven hundred years old, so what the fuck do I know.

There IS a scene with Fergie in a tight nurse's outfit, so the morning wasn't a total loss.

Leave a comment on "How many candy bars are they selling, anyway?"...
ornate line
Hey, has anyone else seen this?

chelseahandler.jpg

I was flipping around on Friday (hangover day) and stopped on something called The Chelsea Handler Show. Like the sign says, I was like...who the hell is this? But it was pretty good. She drinks, smokes and screws too much...basically a guy with breasts. Not a new idea, but she's really good at it. She's all over youtube, so you can see for yourself. Kid Blind Date, Oldies and S Factor are my favorites.

Leave a comment on "Hey, has anyone else seen this?"...
ornate line
Breakfast Links

HeilReilly.jpg

- The 30 second bunnies are back. This time it's Lumberg, Michael Bolton and the boys from Office Space.
- Don't know about you guys, but I'm a mythbusters junkie. Because I need to know if quicksand really exists?
- Tired of missing out on the last Heineken because the family dog beat you to it? Now there's Slobber Lager.
- If you're taking care of business, and Larry David's wife suddenly pops into your head, do you tell him?
- And check out Keith Olbermann on the Tonight Show. I was gonna use a shot of the bunnies until I saw this.

Leave a comment on "Breakfast Links"...
ornate line
Sieg Meow


kitler213.jpg

You can rest easy, there's finally a website devoted to cats who look like Hitler.

Leave a comment on "Sieg Meow"...
 
The
greatest
pop culture
blog on the
planet.
 
Or
maybe not.

The 2008 Weblog Awards

Most Popular Stories

rss feed Breakfast Links Feed

Recent Comments

Free Face
Nothing says "I'm desperate!" better than his website. He's not a handsome guy,
Leonardo Carvalho

You think we're kinda funny
Even if you don't reach #6 or #7, have in mind that you're #1 in my polls! ((If
Leonardo Carvalho

Free Face
Leo, true dat. This guys a moran.
E

One Strong Woman
Loverly...Tim it's okay to go a little Henry Higgins once & a while.
Baierman

A case for cigarettes....
Nah. Frampton Comes Alive, Physical Graffiti and Captain Fantastic.
Tim

You think we're kinda funny
"Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before s
E

Comments Feed

Link Love

Special Features

New to YesButNoButYes?

YesButMailbag